To our very great disappointment, Amnesty International refused to debate with us or Gita Sahgal whose public stand had sparked this important debate. Instead, senior leaders persistently mislead the general public by trying to claim that they were being criticized for defending the rights of terrorist suspects, and they have affirmed their support for Begg. Sadly, Salil Shetty, who is not mired in the failures of the past, seems to have continued with this position. We urge him to clarify his remarks, which as quoted, constitute an attack on the reputation of Gita Sahgal.
Amnesty International has just had an internal review which has validated Gita Sahgal’s allegations, and identified serious failings of ‘due diligence’ by the senior management. You have reflected none of this in your article. But the findings of the review make a debate more urgent than ever.
